I’ve seen a lot of well-meaning posts lately from people trying to educate others about how to talk about oppression our ancestors faced.
They often have an “Instead of ______, say _____” format.
Some of these are great, and they capture some nuance and interject humanity.
For example, “Instead of slave, say enslaved person.” This small language shift keeps a person separate from the oppression they experienced so they are not wholly defined by the crimes committed against them.
But I’ve seen a lot of these that are destructive and erase the complexity of our collective history.
Do you have nightmarish, awful people in your family?
Do you also have wonderful, heroic people in your family?
Do you have utterly unremarkable, average people in your family?
That’s most families.
That’s your ancestors.
In the last 250 years, you’ve had approximately 1,000 ancestors.
Regardless of your heritage, you had wonderful people, monsters, people who made the best of bad situations, people who made the bad situations worse, and everything in between.
Right now, the internet is full of people who identify as white who are trying to hold their ancestors accountable— but they aren’t helping.
A few days ago, I saw one of those posts that turned my stomach. It was telling people to call any mixed race ancestors the products of rape.
…
No. We’re not doing that.
You go, find your ancestors, and learn everything you can about them. People have been having consensual mixed race relationships and intermarriages for hundreds of years on Turtle Island.
Do not assume. Make an educated and informed guess based on observable facts.
Did your ancestors get married, build a life together, and did their will leave everything to their “beloved and faithful spouse”?
Then don’t project onto them the assumption that they were hostages.
If you want to know why your DNA report has mixed ancestry but your family tree does not, then you can do detective work.
Did you have an ancestor or family in your tree often changing their names? Moving a lot (which was much harder, and even life-threatening 100+ years ago)? Did they abandon their home and land with no explanation? Get no inheritance from their families?
Start there.
White abolitionists were often the no-contact, written-out-of-daddy’s-will system disruptors and adult children of the worst offenders of American history.
Many people listed as white weren’t white, either.
People have always been and will forever be attracted to and fall in love with people they’re not socially “allowed” to love.
You had queer ancestors, too.
You had autistic and ADHD ancestors, too.
There’s a strong chance your autistic and ADHD ancestors were the same people as your queer ancestors.
And because the law of odds and averages is sometimes the only law some people can’t break, your neurodivergent ancestors were likely also the ones who gave fewer damns from their damn reservoir about what they were “supposed to do.”
You likely had a lot of ancestors born of non-consensual forced assault, even the ones who were married to pastors of churches.
Yes, history as it is told in American propaganda is whitewashed and sanitized and nationalistic. But don’t disrespect your ancestors by assuming based on zero evidence they had no agency or self-determination.
Tell the stories of individual people after you’ve done your due diligence. And if you haven’t, or the answers aren’t available, then learn what you can from people like Brian Halpin from the Before We Were White Podcast (who just made a really interesting post about seances and the man who played Grandpa on The Waltons being a gay communist. Turns out, Grandma Walton was played by a lesbian, too).
Even if you can’t find a lot of information about your ancestors, you can assume you had some people in your tree who were like you. You can assume you had people in your tree who were like the worst living or recently-deceased relatives you have.
Hopefully, as more records are digitized and more people are tapping into their ancestry, DNA science and technology will continue to give us more answers.
The people who took the most risks are the ones who pushed the bar of progress and extended the outer boundaries of what is considered “acceptable” for future generations.
You are safer today because your iconoclastic/neuroclastic, revolutionary, rebellious, noncompliant, star-stricken Ancestors ignored social boundaries, forfeited wealth and power, ventured boldly into uncharted territory, and occasionally [or frequently, if you’re in my family tree 😅] murdered bad guys.
Honor those people by not erasing them as if every one of your ancestors were this homogenous group.
26% of free American families in 1860 held at least one enslaved person.
Some of those people “owned” family members because it was the safest way to keep their family together.
If you don’t tell those true stories, then you give propagandists and bigots the room to say no-nuance canards like, “But there were Black and Indian slave owners, too.”
Don’t go into conversations like that until you’re prepared to take down their propaganda. Observe those conversations, sit with them, do research, then after you’ve processed— go write about it.
Invite people to add even more nuance in the comments.
0.1% of white American families in 1860 held over 100 enslaved people. Many of those wealthy families still are in the top .1% holding most of America’s capital hostage.
Some are prominent politicians on the Left and Right.
Don’t tell anyone’s story without being honest about when you have to make inferences and giving the reasons you made that assumption so that you don’t accidentally project a false narrative onto history.
But definitely stop instructing others to assume anything without facts related to individuals.
Don’t project helplessness onto your ancestors.
Being choiceless is not being a coward. Being assaulted was a reality for many women, even wives. Forced marriage following an assault was also a life sentence for many women.
But just like you don’t want your will to be undermined by stereotypes, assumptions, and “What others are doing,” don’t tell people to do that to your ancestors. Or mine.
My ancestors didn’t have the same relationship with race, marriage, gender, monogamy, religion, ownership, or any social convention compared to the majority.
Melungeons made a point of disrespecting the conventional order of the status quo.
I resent very much any blanket stereotype that erases them. Do not make them into a footnote. Do not fetishize or romanticize them as being saints.
They risked their lives and lived in the fringes of civilization to do whatever the hell it was they wanted to do.
And some of them left and went on to live within the comforts of the status quo.
Some of them quietly faded into obscurity.
Some of them were big-A Ancestors leading insurrections.
I love Autonomy of thought, mind, and body more than I love safety and belonging and status and comfort and material wealth. That’s what I am looking for when I’m looking at my ancestry— for the ones who are like me.
I love your Autonomy and access to Justice more than I love my own safety, too.
I have a brother who is an EMT and volunteer firefighter. He lives to comfort those who need it. He would give his last crumb away to anyone and does risk his life for others. I look for ancestors who are like him.
I have another brother who is like a more rogue version of Robin Hood. I look for people who are like him.
I have a couple extended family members who are deplorable humans by any objective metric. I am sure they would prefer I not exist. I look for people who remind me of them, too.
I measure success in how much fire, gasoline, and iron will I exert into my own life. I know I have ancestors who were like me.
Y’all know it, too. My family tree is full of antiheroes. Wait until you hear about the man who burned down a whole city. 😁
My ancestors named themselves after the Bible’s bad guys. Cain, Lamech, Devil [Anse], Jezebel, Delilah.
I have ancestors with Pharaoh and Moses as siblings.
Hello, Balthasar Gerard.
Don’t take that history from my ancestors. Don’t take it from me. Don’t take it from your ancestors.
It’s not the “evolved” and progressive thing to erase outliers.
One outlier can do more to shift the world than 500 people occupying the center mass.
Tell their stories.
In my still-living family, just like in yours, there are people who worship hierarchy, status, and wealth, there are system disruptors, and there are as many variations of humans in between as there are people in my family.
My second point is best conveyed via analogy.
Imagine Jake Hexfield, a man whose father— an extremist pastor who was actually more a cult-leader, who was extremely abusive— is running for office. Jesse’s opponent, Dick Bias, is all about “traditional family values.”
In a town hall, Dick Bias talks about his great grandpappy, the farmer of humble means, and how he built a legacy with the sweat of his brow and the work of his hands. Dick’s grandfather started a family business. His daddy started working in the family business as a teen and grew the business to employ hundreds of Americans.
The crowd feels patriotism swelling in their red, white, and blue ramparts.
Jake is asked by the moderator about his own family.
You’re in the audience. You know Jake from college. You know as a teenager, Jake lived with an elderly couple who found him bleeding and with broken bones after his father nearly killed him.
Jake has a choice. He can tell the story of his dad as a God-fearing man who ministered to the sick and dying and did lots of community service, or he can tell the story of a malignant abuser who exploited the vulnerable.
Both stories are true.
What’s also true is that Dick Bias’s great grandpappy “of humble means” was an enslaver and a terrible person, and Bias’s daddy is a greedy profiteer who exploits political loopholes to pay his rural employees far below industry standards.
Dick’s daddy abused him, too, and the whole family knew about it and told no one.
The first story gets Jake more votes.
Right now, many white-identifying Americans are in a similar position to Jake with regards to your ancestors.
Jake didn’t ask to be born to an abuser who exploits people. He has not talked to his father since he was a teenager.
He can uphold propaganda and take the safe route like Dick Bias, or he can stand on his own merits and values, condemning the behavior of his family of origin for the benefit of anyone out there who needs their truth to be heard and their pain validated.
Both Jake and Dick were born into situations they didn’t ask to be born into. One continues to benefit from the sins of his father by upholding lies and only speaking in glittering generalities.
Jake might not win this election if he tells the truth, but he will rearrange the fabric of society if he tells the truth and sides with the ~majority~ who are also covering for abusers at their own expense.
His courage will seep into people’s consciousness. They will never forget that moment. They will be emboldened to stand up and tell hard truths, too.
The number of Americans benefiting from generational wealth is in steep decline. The center cannot hold much longer.
We have an opportunity, as the majority (people who do not benefit from American myths), to work together to forge something better from the wreckage of centuries of colonialism, slavery, eugenics, genocide, and propaganda.
You don’t need to be ashamed of your ancestors. You didn’t ask to be born.
But you don’t have to uphold the lies that make them look like American heroes. You don’t have to keep abiding their legacy of abuse because you don’t want to lose the illusion of safety you get for being compliant.
You can live with intentionality to reverse the harms caused by them.
Do the hard work of learning about true American history in the context of your specific ancestors. It will mean more to you. You’ll have to make inferences and best guesses, and you will never find the whole truth of anything on paper.
But learn what you can and do all things with nuance.
Share the stories of others who tell honest histories.
Breaking the cycle of generational trauma is not done by creating a new false narrative.
Remember that if greed is the root of all evil, oversimplification is the engine that propels it.
Nuance is hard work. If you want to exemplify the American “work ethic,” do the hard work of understanding history, your own and other people’s, and what got you to this pivotal moment in spacetime.



Leave a Reply