I’m going to tell you how purity culture becomes a cult, but I need to first establish that Purity™ is not a reference here to any specific or religious beliefs. It’s a system of moral supremacy that socially rewards strict compliance with group norms and punishes defiance.

Though religion is often used as a way to promote Purity™, it is just one tool in a bigger box of tools used to engineer society.

When I first had my child, I was in a large online parenting forum. It really was helpful for lots of things that I needed to know, and I got advice and reassurance from more experienced parents about a lot of things.

But purity culture is a disease that turns everything it touches into a cult.

Things Got Weird

Then, the forum took a bizarre turn.

One day, there was a post from a woman who had taken a picture of her baby in a car seat. Let’s say her name was “Connie.”

Another woman we will call “Rebecca” didn’t like Connie. They had pre-existing beef.

Rebecca took the opportunity to make a passive-aggressive comment about Connie that could have been taken to imply Connie was a bad and negligent parent.

Are you familiar with the sunk cost fallacy?

The sunk cost fallacy is the tendency to keep investing in something because of the money, time, or effort already spent as opposed to considering if it’s actually worth keeping it up.

All of America’s political systems are sunk cost fallacies, but I digress.

Rebecca was popular in the group with the more progressive parents and Connie with the more conservative parents. The comments got heated, with tons of research articles and monologues about the risks of improper car seat usage.

Someone literally posted a video of a crash test baby (a mannequin-type human simulator) being decapitated in a laboratory crash.

Now, being a psych professional well-versed in identifying… well, lots of things, I could easily see what was happening.

Rebecca was denying being passive-aggressive and faking concern. It would harm her Purity™ score to admit being wrong.

She painted Connie as not only a bad parent, but also unable to take benevolent advice from a real expert, even if the consequences meant death to her child.

Because Rebecca was smart enough to go do research right quick and appear to be an expert on whatever subject, she got away with a multitude of sins.

Connie came back on her fake accounts to troll and call out Rebecca. Then, she acted like a victim again when people accused her of having multiple accounts.

Anyway, the comments became very intense and went on for over 50 pages.

After that thread, though, people became extremist about car seats. They were literally filming local fire departments (where you can usually get car seats installed and instructions on safe use) and reporting them if they didn’t do something right.

They were taking pictures of babies in car seats in grocery store parking lots and license plates and then calling CPS if the parents weren’t using all the best practices. Some even blocked parents from leaving the parking lot.

One day a woman who lived in a rural farm community posted a cute video of her husband driving her and the baby around their property to get the baby to go to sleep. She was holding the drowsy boy in the back seat and the music blasting was a lullaby.

They were driving on a dirt road on their fenced-in farm, maybe going ten or fifteen miles per hour.

That started a frenzy.

People were saying they wouldn’t even drive to the end of their long driveway to check the mail without strapping their baby properly in the seat.

Someone said that an elk could get on their property and charge the car, and this was being taken seriously. Someone else said that a drunk driver could plow through the fence and hit them.

Morbid articles were being posted in the comments about freak accidents.

The group had effectively divided itself into two warring factions, both sides devolving into extremism and abandoning all logic and reason.

They fought so hard that they could not admit they’d gone too far. Sunk cost fallacy and all. Some maybe knew they were being ridiculous and didn’t care. They just felt like they were matching the energy for their team.

But others were almost religious about it. They were that invested.

People were enrolling in classes to be a car seat safety expert.

They were proud of themselves as if they were doing the most noble thing for humanity. They found it honorable to be mocked for their passion. They were saving real lives, and that made it worth the pain of being opposed. Martyrdom.


How Is This Purity Culture?

Purity culture, which demands adherence to a set of rigid standards, thrives on the premise of moral superiority. It forms hierarchies based on compliance.

Purity culture creates an environment wherein individuals are constantly scrutinized and judged based on their compliance with these standards, leading to a cycle of escalating extremism.

In the case of the parenting forum, the initial intent was really just one person throwing a low blow to undermine a parent she didn’t like for reasons unconnected to parenting.

But Rebecca was “progressive.” She couldn’t admit to judging and humiliating another mom because that is against the progressive purity code.

Promoting car seat safety is a commendable act, after all.

Half the people there probably knew what Rebecca was really doing. They either went along with it because they didn’t like Connie or because they were afraid of being on Rebecca’s bad side.

A lot of people there were new parents terrified of doing everything wrong. Many had postpartum anxiety or depression. They were vulnerable, and the intensity of the alarm resonated with the intensity of their anxiety.

For a while, at least, they could give a focus to their anxiety. All that generalized fear now had a laser focus with a path to mastery. Instead of worrying about AllTheThings™, they could focus on what they could change, moving from fear of failure to hero.

The noble cause— car seat safety— was distorted as members weaponized the issue as a means of exerting control and establishing moral dominance over others.

The forum’s environment became less supportive and more punitive, with parents being harshly judged and ostracized for minor deviations from the accepted standard. It gave the “police” a new thing to use to screen people in and out of groups.

Rebecca exemplified how purity culture exploits personal vendettas, pre-existing vulnerabilities, and the social awareness of how to manipulate groups under the guise of moral concern.

By implicating Connie over a minor car seat adjustment, Rebecca was weaponizing the American predisposition to purity culture to marginalize Connie and elevate her own status.

This behavior is typical of cult dynamics, where individuals gain power and influence by demonstrating their adherence to and enforcement of the group’s strict values about— whatever.

The group’s descent into extremism turned into a very stressful and addictive environment. It’s actually addictive trying to keep up with and be accepted into a group like this. It’s like a competitive game.

That’s because it is a game.

Members of this parenting group were surveilling and reporting others and even local strangers to authorities, which brings us to another hallmark of cults: the policing of the community to enforce conformity.

Best believe that these standards were only applied when they could be weaponized and were ignored when a compliant person overstepped.

Surveillance forges an atmosphere of fear and paranoia, so people are even more motivated to perform their purity in public-facing ways. This just solidifies their group standing when they legitimize the leaders.

Compliance will get people public praise, and others will witness it and fall in line. They don’t realize they’re doing it. It just happens, and some people are more wired to imitate social trends.

Standards become more stringent and unreasonable, but no one says anything because they want to avoid being targeted.

The group’s reaction to the rural woman’s video highlights the irrationality that purity culture cultivates. An elk attack?! A drunk driver on a dead end road at noon in South Dakota?!

Purity culture’s emphasis on absolute perfection leads to absurd and impractical lifestyles.

Exhibit A: America.

The division of the group into warring factions, each escalating their commitment to a side, is always how purity culture results in a split that maintains a binary that thrives on conflict and division.

People fight so hard they become entrenched in their positions, losing sight of their common sense. It becomes about loyalty to a side and not the valid issues.

But they have no freedom anymore. They have to choose to go with everything from their side after that. Otherwise, they don’t even have an imperfect community left.

Ultimately, members who might have initially joined for practical advice and camaraderie found themselves enmeshed in a toxic war where they had to constantly prove their moral worth through increasingly extreme behaviors.

And they couldn’t leave.

This happens because we live in a society that was set up to maintain false binaries from its inception because the population can be controlled more easily that way.

That’s why cults of personality prevail every time. That’s why some people get made an example of for a bad day or small mistake while others get away with whatever they want. It’s never really about the values.

It is about building an army with a rank and file.

Leave a Reply

Trending